Metzger Insurance Agency Logo
Protecting Your Assets Since 1925
Get Your Quote Today

What Our Customers Say

★★★★★

"Taya was such a delight and was so helpful! She went above and beyond to help us secure coverage! Overall a great experience and would absolutely recommend!"

- Verified Google Review
★★★★★

"Taya Brady at Metzger Insurance was a life saver. We bought a fixer upper and had a hard time finding the right insurance. She took down my info and had a quote for us the next day! She was a delight to work with."

- Verified Google Review
★★★★★

"I had a difficult insurance situation and tried several other insurance companies that couldn't take care of me. Chance stayed in communication and took care of everything I needed. Great experience"

- Verified Google Review
★★★★★

"Chance Sowers did an amazing job expediting my paperwork with many obstacles. I couldn't be more pleased"

- Verified Google Review
★★★★★

"We love Metzger Insurance! We've been with them for 23 yrs. They are always quick to answer our questions, help us with the best policy and have the best customer service! I love chit chatting with the ladies- they feel like family."

- Verified Google Review
★★★★★

"Cassie provided me and guided me thru a very smooth transition from a former insurance company to there's. She found me some really great rates and I'm very grateful for all her efforts to get a great policy."

- Verified Google Review
★★★★★

"Drema has been absolutely fantastic to work with. She is very knowledgeable and can answer your questions quickly. Changes in my policy that need to be made are done right then. I couldn't recommend a better Insurance company!"

- Verified Google Review
★★★★★

"Mallory is a true blessing to our company! She has been extremely helpful in getting the right coverage that we need for our rental properties and our trucking business. She is very professional and is available anytime we need her."

- Verified Google Review
★★★★★

"I have taken my agricultural operation and moved to Metzger insurance. Mallory Gibson has been great to work with very knowledgeable. She always responds the next day even to my odd hours messages!"

- Verified Google Review
★★★★★

"I gave this rating for excellent customer service! Cassie Maddux was amazing with helping me set up my policy and she always keeps me updated on any changes. I appreciate the holiday e-mails as well. Thanks!"

- Verified Google Review
Read All Reviews on Google

Our Insurance Services

Commercial Insurance

Comprehensive business protection including liability, property, and workers' compensation coverage.

Farm & Crop Insurance

Specialized agricultural coverage protecting your farm operations, equipment, and crop investments.

Cannabis Insurance

Tailored coverage for cannabis businesses including product liability and regulatory compliance.

Cyber & Crypto Insurance

Modern protection against cyber threats, data breaches, and cryptocurrency-related risks.

Pet Insurance

Keep your furry family members healthy with comprehensive veterinary care coverage.

Home Insurance

Protect your most valuable investment with comprehensive homeowners and renters insurance.

Auto Insurance

Reliable vehicle protection with competitive rates and excellent customer service.

Life Insurance

Secure your family's financial future with comprehensive life insurance coverage and planning.

AI Assistant

Meet CORA,
Your Insurance AI Assistant

Experience the future of insurance with CORA, our AI-powered assistant that combines blockchain technology with natural language processing to provide instant, accurate support.

Instant policy information, underwriting and quote support

Blockchain-verified proof of humanity

24/7 intelligent agent, carrier and customer support

Try CORA Now

Get Your Quote Today

Ready to Protect What Matters Most?

With nearly 100 years of experience, we believe in personal service and direct communication. Skip the forms and speak directly with our expert team. We're here to provide you with personalized insurance solutions tailored to your unique needs.

Call Us

740-986-4871

Speak directly with our experienced agents. Get instant answers and personalized quotes over the phone.

Call Now

Text Us

740-421-4090

Quick questions? Send us a text! We'll respond promptly with the information you need.

Send Text

Email Us

info@metzgerinsuranceagency.com

Prefer email? Send us your insurance questions and we'll provide detailed quotes and information.

Send Email

Business Hours

Monday - Friday: 8:30 AM - 4:30 PM

Saturday & Sunday: Closed

Emergency claims assistance available 24/7

Why Choose Metzger Insurance Agency?

Nearly 100 Years of Experience

Since 1925, we've been protecting families and businesses with trusted insurance solutions through generations.

Personal Service

Real insurance professionals who take the time to understand your unique needs and provide expert guidance.

Comprehensive Coverage

From traditional home and auto to specialized cannabis and cyber insurance - we protect what matters most.

Community Trust

A cornerstone of the community for nearly a century, built on relationships and exceptional service.

Competitive Rates

We work with multiple carriers to find you the best coverage at the most competitive rates available.

Ongoing Support

From claims assistance to policy updates, we're here to support you every step of the way.